Pedagogy Adapted to the KENET ToT

The teaching and learning methodology is a four-step progressive / recursive design adapted from experiential education theory. Using this methodology, material covered during this training will be systematically presented (Step A), practiced (Step B), assessed (Step C) and reviewed (Step D). Starting at the top of the circle to the right, Step A represents the introduction to new materials such as theory and skills. Progressing to Step B, participants will practice the application of the newly presented materials. Once applied, participants will assess their work in Step C, which will lead to a reflection or review of lessons learned in Step D that will inform and influence the next progressive iteration the learning cycle, beginning with Step A.

A full progression of this methodology will be attempted each day of the training event. For example, the first day of this training will focus on the fundamentals of eLearning, where materials will be presented during the initial part of the day (Step A) and learning activities centered on the application of these materials will be conducted during the latter part (Step B). Concluding the day, participants will be asked to assess their understanding of the fundamentals of eLearning (Step C) and to identify questions and unresolved related issues for the next day’s session (Step D). The second day will build on the materials introduced and practiced during the first and will be guided by the participants’ assessment and reflection on the lessons learned form the first day. This training is progressive in that each step builds on the previous. This training is recursive in that the material presented in one day is reviewed and applied in a subsequent day.

To maximize the productive output of this training activity, participants should bring digital materials for an online course they wish to build. Digital materials should include a syllabus, readings, lecture notes and presentations, graphics, pictures, assessments, and bibliography.

eLearning

"... the effective teaching and learning process created by combining e-digital content with local community and tutor support along with global community engagement."

Learning Outcomes

After completing this lesson, you will be able to:

• Search for more definitions of eLearning and related terms
• Define eLearning taking into consideration the context of your institution
• Explain the divergence and convergence in meaning of:
  
  • distance learning
    
  • online education
    
  • distributed learning
    
  • Internet education
    
  • computer-based training
    
  • computer-mediated communication
    
  • computer-assisted instruction
    
  • virtual education
    
  • cyber learning
    
  • multi-modal instruction

The Basics of eLearning

eLecture

eLearning uses learning management systems (such as Blackboard, WebCT, KEWL, etc.) as a web-based platform for distributing and facilitating the eLearning curricula. Learning management systems allow for effective use of the Web for learning by:

• Providing access to rich sources of information.
• Encouraging meaningful interactions with content.
• Bringing people together to challenge, support, or respond to each other.
  

Exemplary eLearning courses should have the following aspects:

• eLectures – eLectures provide crucial concept or technique that students need in order to apply it to a problem or discussion.
  
• Discussion Forum – This is where online interaction takes place for each course. You will be expected to initiate a discussion and post replies.
  
• Ask an expert – In addition to the local learning facilitator, you will have access to an expert practitioner for each course. This expert practitioner will be available to generate discussion about a particular topic and to respond to questions.
  
• Mentorship – If you require an online mentor who is a professional in a particular subject area and who can provide ongoing feedback let your course instructor know so we can help locate an online mentor for you.
  
• Local learning facilitator or tutor support – A local learning facilitators and/or lecturer will be available for face to face interaction at your Home Institution.
  
• Access to network resources - Additional reading materials relevant to your course are located in “Course documents”. Moreover, some assignments will require that you locate material on the Internet for sharing in the conference room or discussion forum.
  
• Structured group activity – You will be expected to participate in a combination of the following structured group activities: seminars, small group discussions, learning partnerships and dyads, student work groups and learning circles, team presentations, simulations or role plays, and peer learning groups. Please get some guidance from your course instructor or local learning facilitator.
  
• Informal peer interaction -- Sometimes the best learning occurs during informal peer interaction so please email each other if you require private space.
  

Connected Education

Of the various related terms and definitions, I appreciate Steven Gilbert (2000:15) vision of connected education. “In this vision of education, individual learners, teachers, and related support professionals connect better to information, ideas and each other via effective combinations of pedagogy and technology – both old and new.” Gilbert continues that “within the context of the institution’s educational mission, all have more opportunities to connect with each other’s efforts to identify, understand, develop, and improve effective combinations of:

• Learners’ capabilities, needs, and goals;
  
• Teachers’ capabilities, needs, and goals;
  
• Academic content;
  
• Approaches to teaching and learning (pedagogy);
  
• Media and applications of technology; and
  
• Assessment and Feedback.”
  

e-Quality: Access to Quality eLearning

Before we proceed, let's take some time to look at quality assurance concerns that started to be voiced as more traditional universities started to offer Internet-based distance learning and as more private sector entities started to offer diplomas based entirely on computer-mediated learning. The eight regional accrediting commissions which assure the quality of the great majority of degree-granting institutions of higher learning in the United States issued a statement of commitment about their resolve to sustain certain values in the face of greater movement towards Internet-based distance learning (not as we have defined eLearning above). These values are:

• that education is best experienced within a community of learning where competent professionals are actively and cooperatively involved with creating, providing, and improving the instructional program;
  
• that learning is dynamic and interactive, regardless of the setting in which it occurs;
  
• that instructional programs leading to degrees having integrity are organized around substantive and coherent curricula which define expected learning outcomes;
  
• that institutions accept the obligation to address student needs related to, and to provide the resources necessary for, their academic success;
  
• that institutions are responsible for the education provided in their name;
  
• that institutions undertake the assessment and improvement of their quality, giving particular emphasis to student learning;
  
• that institutions voluntarily subject themselves to peer review.

Based on an initial draft by the Western Cooperative for Educational Telecommunications (http://www.wiche.edu/telecom/), the eight regional accrediting commissions offered the following best practices to reflect the “common understandings of those elements that reflect quality distance education programming.” The best practices are meant to assist institutions in planning distance education activities and to provide a self-assessment framework for those already nvolved and are intended to inform and facilitate the evaluation policies and processes of each region. These Best Practices are divided into five separate components, each of which addresses a particular area of institutional activity relevant to distance education. They are:

• Institutional Context and Commitment
• Curriculum and Instruction
• Faculty Support
• Student Support
• Evaluation and Assessment

Blackboard Inc and the U.S. National Education Association (NEA) commissioned a study on “Quality on the Line: Benchmarks for Success in Internet-Based Distance Education”. The study set out to validate a set of benchmarks applicable to Internet-based distance education.The study outcome is a list of 24 benchmarks, grouped under seven general categories that are essential to ensure quality in Internet-based distance education. The seven categories are:

• Institutional Support Benchmarks
  
• Course Development Benchmarks
  
• Teaching/Learning Benchmarks
  
• Course Structure Benchmarks
  
• Student Support Benchmarks
  
• Faculty Support Benchmarks
  
• Evaluation and Assessment Benchmarks
  

These are the very same benchmarks used for addressing quality in traditional on-campus education. For example, the core criteria for education and training providers in South Africa include the following:

• Policy statement
  
• Quality management systems
  
• Review mechanisms
  
• Programme delivery
  
• Staff policies
  
• Learner policies
  
• Assessment policies
  
• Management system and policies
  

These core criteria are reflected in the Quality Evaluation Guide prepared by the Association of African Universities. Included in the quality evaluation are: performance areas and some related quality indicators include vision, mission, goals and objectives; teaching and learning; assessment; research; organizational and management structure; planning, budgeting and human resources; campus and community relations; facilities; norms, values and ethics; gender equity; new technologies; internationalization; response to changing social demands. I am not sure to what extent this quality evaluation guide has been tested with distance education programs in Africa. For quality assurance purposes, institutions in Africa, such as the University of Dar es Salaam, are recognizing the need to prepare for an Internet-based on-campus and off-campus education. They are reviewing the applicability to their own situation of the “Quality on the Line: Benchmarks for Success in Internet-Based Distance Education.”

Related Terms to eLearning

Related terms include Distance Education, Online Education, Distributed Learning, Internet Education, Computer-based Training, Computer-Mediated Communication, Computer-Assisted Instruction, Virtual Education, Cyber-Learning, Asynchronous Learning, and Multi-modal Instruction. The meaning of these terms are starting to converge. Where there is a difference in usage is explained by place (same place, any place, on-campus, off-campus); time (same time -- synchronous or not at the same time -- asynchronous); interaction (learner to computer; learner to instructor; learner to other learners); use of the computer (presentation, interactive, collaborative, generative); type of technology (text, audio, video, multimedia); and absence or presence of face-to-face interaction.

Here are some basic definitions and characteristics of these related terms:

Distance Education

Barry Willis (1995) considers distance education as taking place "when a teacher and student(s) are separated by physical distance, and technology (i.e., voice, video, data, and print), often in concert with face-to-face communication, is used to bridge the instructional gap." Willis (1995) indicates that "these types of programs can provide adults with a second chance at a college education, reach those disadvantaged by limited time, distance or physical disability, and update the knowledge base of workers at their places of employment.”

Traditional high-end distance education technologies require special-purpose equipment or services (video-conferencing rooms, satellite uplinks). At the low end, reliance on public services designed for one-way broadcast (such as television) or point-to-point connections (the switched telephone network), severely limit the interaction between participants.

Online Education

Greg Kearsley (1997) defines Online Education as follows:

“OnLine Education allows the study of higher education courses through the electronic medium of Internet. Course Materials, including reference papers, study materials and contact with tutors and fellow students are all accessed through the use of personal computers and telecommunications.”

Kearsley continues:

“OnLine Education allows students previously unknown freedom to study at virtually any location and at any pace that can accommodate their other commitments such as work and family. Diploma, undergraduate and masters degrees, the duration of which is a maximum of five years, can be studied at day or night from home, office and even hotel room if you are a frequent traveler.”

Kearsley indicated that online learning affords learner's great flexibility in terms of location and duration of study. He also suggests that additional plus is that online courses "are also highly regarded by both the academic and business community.”

Here is yet another definition of online learning:

“Simply put, online learning refers to learning and other supportive resources that are available through a computer. The computer prompts the learner for more information and presents appropriate material based on the learner’s response.” ( Carliner 1998).

Carliner's definition suggests a "learner to computer" interaction whereas other definitions highlight "online interaction" also historically called "computer mediated communication" (CMC), although this term covers applications beyond instruction (e.g., decision-making in work teams).”
Electronic Collaboration: a Practical Guide for Educators (1999:1) states that

"Internet-based work allows collaborators to communicate anytime, from anywhere to any place. People from different parts of a building, state, country, or continent can exchange information, collaborate on shared documents and ideas, study together, or reflect on their own practices.”

A comprehensive definition from Department of Education, Training and Employment (South Australia) follows:

"Online Education courses are conducted through the Internet, allowing you to receive and submit course work and interact with participants and your professor via your computer and modem. The predominantly asynchronous nature of the lessons, activities and communication methods allows you to participate in courses at times and places convenient to you."

Distributed Learning

Oblinger and Maruyama (1996:6) characterizes a distributed learning environment as follows:

"where the learning environment exists among a dispersed student population, is structured according to learners' needs, and tends to integrate traditional institutional functions (e.g. classroom and library)."

Internet Education

Using the Internet to teach. The Internet is the "network of networks" or a global computer connection, that allows any user (called a client with an Internet connection) to access information on any other computer that furnishes it.

Computer-Based Training (CBT)

Training (of humans) done by interaction with a computer. The programs and data used in CBT are known as "courseware."

Computer-Mediated Communication (CMC)

Computer-Mediated Communication that takes place through, or is facilitated by, computers. Examples include Usenet and
e-mail, but CMC also covers real-time chat tools like lily, IRC, and even video conferencing.

Computer-Assisted Instruction

In a one hundred percent computer-assisted instruction program, "the computer takes over from the teacher in providing the learner with drill, practice, and revision, as well as testing and diagnosis". The teaching may be linear or branching, or extended to thinking and problem solving through simulation. However, learner's responses are limited to a prescribed set of multiple choices. Free, creative responses, cannot yet be accommodated.

Virtual Education

Virtual education is the use of information and communication technologies (ICTs) to deliver educational programs and courses. Farrell (1999, p2) reports that "the label virtual is widely and indiscriminately used around the world and frequently used interchangeably with other labels such as open and distance learning, distributed learning, networked learning, Web-based learning, and computer learning."

Cyber-Learning

Cyber Learning is an innovative approach to higher education on the Internet. Students take courses from home, office or other convenient locations at times that fit their schedule.

Asynchronous Learning Networks (ALN)

The ALN Center defines Asynchronous Learning Networks (ALN) as "people networks for anytime - anywhere learning. " ALN "combines self-study with substantial, rapid, asynchronous interactivity with others." In ALN, "learners use computer and communications technologies to work with remote learning resources, including coaches and other learners, but without the requirement to be online at the same time. The most common ALN communication tool is the World Wide Web.” ALN, by this definition, includes: a web-based workshop that requires frequent online conferencing and collaboration with others; a text- or computer-based training course that requires learners to use email to discuss assignments with each other and with the training coach or facilitator; a proctored examination at a specified time and place; occasional synchronous chat or lab sessions for near-campus learners, or face to face kickoff meeting. By the above definition, what is NOT ALN includes: distance education based primarily on a synchronous audio or video presentation or conference requiring learners and instructors to be available at the same time; a videotaped course or mail-based correspondence course or computer-based training with no substantial and rapid interactivity with others, even though the learner might mail in a paper or test and receive a reply days later.

Blended learning and multi-modal instruction

This term is often used when learning takes advantage of the best aspects of in-person or face-to-face interaction and e-learning technologies.

Thus, blended learning comes closest to the following NetTel definition of eLearning.

Learning Tasks

These learning tasks and activities build on your learning tasks and activities from Lesson 1.

Read

http://www.press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/075117.html Using Electronic Resources for Teaching Excerpted from pages 143-67 of The Chicago Handbook for Teachers: A Practical Guide to the College Classroom by Alan Brinkley, Betty Dessants, Michael Flamm, Cynthia Fleming, Charles Forcey, and Eric Rothschild, published by the University of Chicago Press. ©1999 by the University of Chicago.

Search

1. Using your favorite seach engine, locate additional online resources that define or explain eLearning.
   
2. Be ready to explain what you liked or did not like about the additional resources you have located.
   

Interview

1. Interview someone from the telecommunications sector and someone from the education sector. Before you begin, explain to your interviewees that you are doing a learning task or activity about the importance of eLearning and the definition of eLearning; request their permission to use their responses for the discussion forum; and ask whether they wish to be named or to be anonymous.
2. Interview someone from the telecommunications sector and ask for a summary explanation of
   
   1. policy objectives in the telecommunications sector and in the education sector
      
   2. what synergies might there be between telecommunications policy objectives and education policy objectives
      
   3. how telecommunications objectives can assist in the achievement of education policy objectives
      
   4. what the implications are of telecommunications policy objectives on eLearning
      
   5. why eLearning might be important or not important for broader development goals of the country
      
3. Do the same interview from someone from the education sector.

Discuss

Go into the discussion forum and post the results of your interview. As you discuss with your peer group:

1. Share insights about how you phrased your questions.
2. Compare and contrast the responses from the two interviewees. Posit an explanation of the difference or similarity in their responses.
   
3. Connect the responses of the interviewees to the importance or lack of importance of eLearning and to a definition of eLearning.

Create

Add 2 few more slides to your powerpoint presentation (which you have started after completing Lesson 1) that explain how you define eLearning taking into consideration your local context.

Learning Assessment

1) Assess yourself by reflecting on the following:

• Define eLearning taking into consideration the context of your institution
  
• Explain the divergence and convergence in meaning of:
  • distance learning
    
  • online education
    
  • distributed learning
    
  • Internet education
    
  • computer-based training
    
  • computer-mediated communication
    
  • computer-assisted instruction
    
  • virtual education
    
  • cyber learning
    
  • multi-modal instruction

2) Points towards final grade

• Participation in the discussion forum = 1 point
  
• Quality of participation in the discussion forum = 2 points
  
• Powerpoint slides = 1 point